All posts

NCT vs OKR: Same, same but different!

Setting and achieving goals can be a challenging task. It requires a clear understanding of the company's strategy, open communication, and alignment of all tasks. This is why many companies use the OKR (Objectives and Key Results) methodology to facilitate the goal-setting process.

However, in the past years, there has been a growing aversion toward OKRs due to misunderstandings surrounding them. Oftentimes teams get confused by vague Objectives and feel overwhelmed by the lack of guidance in OKRs. As a result, the NCTs (Narrative, Commitments, Task) framework has been gaining popularity as a possible alternative to OKRs.

But what exactly are NCTs? How do they differ from OKRs and are they really necessary? This article answers all of these questions and also shows how you can set up NCTs within Mooncamp.

TL;DR
  • Same idea, new labels: NCTs (Narrative, Commitments, Tasks) are essentially OKRs with a few opinionated adjustments to format and to how ambition is labelled.
  • Three elements compared: Narratives are story-driven Objectives written out in a few sentences that say why the goal matters to the business, Commitments are three to five measurable goals per narrative that the team commits to meeting in full (stretch commitments are marked as such), Tasks map cleanly to OKR initiatives.
  • The hype is a symptom: Most preference for NCTs comes from common OKR myths, that Objectives must be aspirational, that OKRs motivate by themselves, or that they cannot be changed mid-cycle.
  • Choose by team maturity: Experienced teams thrive with the flexibility of OKRs, while teams that need clearer guidance often benefit from the more prescriptive NCT format.

💡 Reminder: OKR (short for "Objectives and Key Results") is an agile framework for formulating and implementing strategic goals in companies that consists of three core elements:

  • Objectives: What do I want to achieve?
  • Key Results: How do I know that the goal has been achieved?
  • Initiatives: How do I achieve the objective?

Google's OKR guide recommends three to five Objectives with around three Key Results each (Google re:Work). The output is mapped in initiatives (= concrete activities). More basic knowledge can be found in our OKR guide.

What are NCTs (Narrative, Commitments, Tasks)?

Ravi Mehta, a former chief product officer at Tinder, created NCTs as a goal-setting framework for product teams (Reforge, 2023). He says his team first used it at Tripadvisor (First Round Review, 2022). Much like OKRs, NCTs help teams set and execute goals for a fixed period, usually a quarter, using narratives, commitments and tasks to bridge the gap between strategy and execution. In sum, NCTs aim to clarify the strategy, goals and required steps toward achieving the goals.

Narratives

Establishing the narrative is the first step when working with NCTs since they are used to convey the goal to the team, just like the Objectives of the OKR method.

A narrative is a short qualitative description of what a team wants to achieve within a quarter and why it matters to the business. Narratives also answer the question “Why now?”. Reforge puts it at one or two sentences; Mehta recommends "a few sentences", a little longer than a typical OKR Objective (First Round Review, 2022). A narrative uses elements of storytelling to tie the goal to the company’s business strategy, thus explaining the goal’s contextual relevance. This in turn provides clarity for all involved parties.

Narrative example: Our marketing still speaks only to our original audience, and growth there has stalled. This quarter we reach new audiences with a cross-platform campaign and a rebuilt website, so the next product launch has people ready to hear about it.

Commitments

Commitments are aligned under the narrative and resemble the Key Results in OKRs. They are measurable goals that depict how much progress is being made toward the achievement of the narratives. A narrative usually has three to five of them: objectively measurable goals the team commits to reaching by the end of the quarter. Mehta describes commitments as "meant to be done", with "a hundred percent target accuracy", but not every commitment has to reach 100%: a team can take on stretch commitments, as long as it is clear which ones it can deliver for certain and which are a stretch (First Round Review, 2022). Reforge describes the same split as critical versus aspirational commitments (Reforge, 2023).

Commitment examples:

  • Increase organic website traffic by 25% by the end of the quarter
  • Get 30 people to subscribe to our blog by the end of the quarter
  • Increase the number of social media followers by 15% by the end of Q2

Tasks

Tasks are the specific actions that a team sets for itself in order to achieve the respective commitments. The task list is not set in stone and can be adjusted throughout the cycle. Tasks that are deemed irrelevant later on can also be removed.

As hinted at above, NCTs bear many resemblances to OKRs, seeing as both frameworks consist of similar elements, like Objectives and narratives, commitments and Key Results, or tasks and initiatives.

NCTs vs OKRs: What’s the difference?

The newfound hype towards NCTs raises an important question – how exactly are they different from OKRs?

In truth, NCTs are just an opinionated version of OKRs with a few key adjustments:

NCT vs OKR infographic

NCT

OKR

Goal

Narrative: one to a few sentences on what the team wants to achieve this quarter and why it matters to the business

Objective: a short statement of what the team wants to achieve

Measure

Commitments: usually three to five measurable goals per narrative, meant to be met in full; stretch commitments are marked as such

Key Results: around three per Objective; committed OKRs should reach 100%, while for aspirational OKRs Google counts a score of 0.7 or more as on track

Execution

Tasks: the actions the team plans to reach its commitments, adjustable during the quarter

Initiatives: the projects and tasks that move the Key Results

Difference between narratives and Objectives

Perhaps the most notable difference between the two frameworks can be found when comparing narratives and Objectives.

Although they’re both a type of goal, narratives tend to say more than Objectives: a few sentences that use elements of storytelling to explain what the goal is and the strategy behind it. Unlike Objectives, narratives also explain why the goal is relevant to the overall business goal. They also hint at how it should be achieved.

Objectives, on the other hand, are usually more concise and solely focus on depicting the team’s specific goal. It is then up to the leaders to explain and communicate the relevance of the Objective. However, due to the flexible nature of OKRs, Objectives can also be formulated as narratives if that is to a team's liking.

NCT example:

Narrative: To do our part in saving the planet we must become the leading provider of eco-friendly cleaning products, promote sustainable practices, reduce the environmental impact of cleaning products, and become role models in the sustainability market.

Commitment 1: Achieve a 30% increase in sales revenue from new markets within the next cycle.

Tasks:

  • Conduct market research to identify potential target markets and consumer segments
  • Develop marketing strategies tailored to the identified target markets
  • Establish distribution partnerships in the new markets to expand product reach

Commitment 2: Enhance product sustainability and reduce carbon footprint by achieving a 20% reduction in packaging waste.

Tasks:

  • Research and source eco-friendly packaging materials
  • Redesign product packaging to incorporate recyclable and compostable materials
  • Implement recycling programs and educate customers on proper disposal practices

Commitment 3: Increase customer satisfaction ratings by 15% based on post-purchase surveys.

Tasks:

  • Train customer service representatives on product knowledge and effective communication
  • Implement a customer feedback system and address customer concerns promptly
  • Personalize customer interactions and offer loyalty rewards for repeat purchases

OKR example:

Objective: Increase market share in the eco-friendly cleaning product industry.

Key Results:

  • Achieve a 10% increase in market share within this cycle
  • Reduce packaging waste by 20%
  • Increase customer satisfaction ratings by 15%

Difference between commitments and Key Results

When it comes down to commitments and Key Results, the two frameworks share more similarities than differences.

Commitments and Key Results are the same concept at their core: they measure how much progress is being made toward a goal.

The only difference is where the ambition is labelled. In NCTs, commitments are meant to be met in full, and a team marks any stretch commitments one by one. OKRs draw the line for the whole OKR: a committed OKR should score 1.0, or 100%, while for aspirational OKRs Google counts a score of 0.7 or more as on track (What Matters).

In sum, Key Results play the role of firm commitments when the OKR is committed, and of stretch commitments when it is aspirational.

Differences between tasks and OKR initiatives

When working with OKRs, Key Results are typically complemented by OKR initiatives. These initiatives are nothing more than tasks or projects that need to be done in order to achieve the Key Results.

So in reality, OKR initiatives are exactly the same as the NCT tasks. The only difference is that initiatives are not an explicit part of the OKR acronym.

Are NCTs better than OKRs?

Let’s wrap up what we learned:

OKRs are a flexible goal management framework. The OKR framework can be molded into the NCT framework by adjusting just a few parameters. For instance, Objectives can be written in more detail and explain why the goal matters to the business and address the “why now?” so that they resemble the narratives from NCTs. OKRs can also be labelled committed or aspirational, the same line NCTs draw between firm and stretch commitments. And lastly, OKR initiatives are essentially the same as NCT tasks.

So why are NCTs gaining a reputation for being better than OKRs?

In truth, the growing preference towards NCTs is caused by misconceptions and a lack of understanding about OKRs.

For example, the statement “NCTs are better for cross-functional teams than OKRs” is becoming more common. The alleged reason is that OKRs do not provide enough context in regard to why they are important to the company and different teams. This is, however, false. If implemented and communicated correctly, OKRs can be extremely useful and help cross-functional teams thrive.

When the benefits and implementation process of OKRs are not understood, mistakes can easily be made. As a consequence, OKRs are perceived as a tedious and frustrating tool instead of a helpful management framework.

Next up, common misunderstandings about OKRs and why they fail will be resolved.

Why OKRs fail

When speaking of OKRs it is often mentioned that they increase autonomy, productivity, and motivation. But how do they achieve this?

Introducing OKRs shouldn’t be seen as a magical solution. OKR can be a powerful framework for goal-setting and management, but it entails effort. Constant communication and collaboration across teams are required. This can only be achieved if the leaders in charge of the OKRs understand the framework and can successfully explain it to the teams involved.

When leaders fail to understand OKRs, they tend to fall for the myths and misconceptions surrounding the framework. This can lead to the wrong Objectives being set or to miscommunications. As such, many of the problems revolving around OKRs are due to a lack of understanding. So what are some common myths surrounding OKRs?

OKR myths

Objectives have to be aspirational and challenging

Often OKRs are associated with challenging and unrealistic goals. Although teams can set aspirational goals, Objectives can also be tailored to a team's preference. This means that teams can also choose to set committed instead of aspirational OKRs. Furthermore, in case you set aspirational OKRs, leaders should make sure that they are not too aspirational so that they could never be achieved and teams get demotivated.

OKRs magically motivate employees

One of the benefits of OKR is the flexibility it offers since teams can choose their initiatives and help choose the Key Results. This can lead to higher levels of accountability and increase the involvement and motivation of the teams. However, teams can only be held accountable if they truly understand the Objective and OKR process.

Simply setting a goal does not instigate motivation. Team members require clarity to feel confident enough to work independently and in turn feel motivated. For this reason, executives must explain both the reason for introducing OKRs, the OKR process, and the goals themselves repeatedly to make sure that employees understand it. This is also why writing effective OKRs requires constant team communication and collaboration. In sum, OKRs do motivate employees, but only if they are explained and communicated properly.

OKRs are fixed and cannot be changed

Believing that OKRs cannot be changed or adapted is a grave misunderstanding of OKRs. In truth, setting OKRs is only a fraction of the work. Objectives and their Key Results must then be checked regularly and adjusted if necessary. Besides that, OKRs can also be changed to better fit a company’s needs. For example, Objectives can follow a different format, e.g. that of a narrative. This allows the OKR system to grow and develop alongside the team.

Tip: OKR workshops help leaders understand and set effective OKRs. By taking part in OKR workshops companies can reduce the risk of failure.

Conclusion: NCTs or OKRs?

By better communicating what the OKR framework is and what it isn’t, leaders can address the root causes of why some employees feel frustrated when working with OKRs.

Furthermore, based on a common understanding of the flexibility of the framework, OKRs can be shaped into a tool that is identical to NCTs. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference or what works best for your organization.

As such, OKRs might be better for experienced teams that prefer complete autonomy and stretch goals. NCTs on the other hand, might be better suited for teams that require more guidance and concrete steps.

Tip: Companies struggling to organize and execute OKRs can benefit from a dedicated OKR software.

Regardless if you want to roll out OKRs or NCTs in your company, the best strategy execution tools will give you the freedom (and the structure) to make the rollout a success.

Setting up NCTs with Mooncamp

Mooncamp (our product) lets you rename goal types and add your own, so you can run NCTs in the same tool you use for OKRs.

To set up NCTs, an admin goes to Settings > Goals > Types and rules and either adds narrative, commitment and task types with the New button or renames the pre-defined Objective and Key Result types and adds a task type.

After setting up the NCT goal types, go back to the goal overview and set the type of each goal to narrative, commitment or task.

Try Mooncamp for free

FAQ: Narrative, Commitments, Tasks

Are NCTs better than OKRs?
In short: No. NCTs are just a version of OKRs. After all, OKRs can be adjusted to reflect both the terminology as well as the NCT framework's rules.
What is the main difference between NCTs and OKRs?
The key difference is that narratives are short stories, a few sentences long, that explain a goal and why it matters to the business. They use storytelling to show why the goal is important right now and give hints on how to achieve it. Unlike Objectives, which are shorter and to the point, narratives tell a bigger story. Lastly, commitments work like Key Results: usually three to five measurable goals per narrative that the team commits to meeting in full, plus any stretch commitments it marks as such.

Related Articles

Try Mooncamp for free